Fear and Loathing in KDE Land?

-

Full disclosure: My only contributions to KDE project are several bug reports and perhaps a few new users. So my qualifications to comment on the issue is of course almost non-existent. But hey, I've been a faithful KDE user for all these years, and so I think I have some right to make comments at least from a user's perspective.
-------

There's been some discussions on KDE land regarding replacing Nepomuk (or Nepomuk-KDE for the politically correct) with a new project named Baloo.

The Baloo project is headed by KDE developer Vishesh Handa, who apparently was very much involved in Nepomuk as well. Baloo wasn't announced officially to the 'public' till now, but thanks to recent Phoronix articles, it's been gaining some attention. The article titled "KDE's Nepomuk Doesn't Seem To Have A Future" went on to say:

"It appears there isn't much of a future left to KDE's Nepomuk framework that was developed at a cost of 17 million Euros... It's going to be replaced going forward in the KDE land."

The tone of the article hasn't pleased everybody. Now there's some storm on KDE promo mailing list with KDE guru Aaron Seigo suggesting that the new project should've been branded as just another version of Nepomuk. Many members, and especially Vishesh Handa, the project maintainer are opposed to this idea and want Baloo to remain as a new project, one that replaces Nepomuk.

I've been a moderate fan of Seigo, but reading through the mailing list, I couldn't stand the stink of his PR bullshit.

Some things that everybody (even Seigo) seem to agree on:
  • Nepomuk wasn't the greatest piece of software
  • It hasn't got any love from users
  • The 'semantic features' introduced by Nepomuk had few users
  • Baloo is significantly better and faster than Nepomuk ever was

As for me, the very news that Nepomuk is going to be removed is reason to rejoice. Nepomuk was a f**ked-up useless piece of bloat-ware. For some reason, its proponents were pushing the idea that 'rating and tagging your files' was the next big thing that users want to do. Then there was this desktop indexing/search that would suck the juice out of your desktop experience - something Java does to your online experience.
In fact, disabling desktop search and Nepomuk is the first thing I do after a fresh installation of Fedora. I wonder if Nepomuk had as many happy users as it had developers and PR dudes!

Seigo seems to think that Nepomuk-KDE (and KDE's association with Europian Union project) is something to boast about and he apparently fears that the PR team would lose this if they are to switch to Baloo. He proposes to brand Baloo as Nepomuk v2 (or v3 or whatever) so that the awkward situation of accepting Nepomuk's failure can be avoided or at least soothed.

I'd say that a press release announcing the death of Nepomuk-KDE would only evoke positive emotions from users. One may hide behind euphemisms and other PR tricks, but the facts of the case are undisputed.

------
Read the mailing list entries:






Comments

  1. J StorySaturday, March 22, 2014 at 8:37:00 AM GMT+5:30

    Nepomuk's replacement, Baloo, also sucks. I don't want what it's offering and, most importantly, I don't appreciate that this useless (to me) garbage is stifling the performance of everything else. If it had the decency to operate invisibly in the background, without impacting anything else, then even if I didn't use it, at least I wouldn't be reminded of its existence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. SyamSaturday, March 22, 2014 at 11:08:00 AM GMT+5:30

      Oops.. sorry to hear that Baloo isn't working too well for you. I'll probably give it a go once it's available from official Fedora distribution. Anyway, at least you can disable it if you don't want to use it. That's what I always do.

      I don't think there'll be any performance impact once you disable indexing and desktop search from system settings. Am I wrong here?

      Delete
    2. VisheshMonday, March 31, 2014 at 8:40:00 PM GMT+5:30

      Could you please report bugs regarding how it was 'stifling your performance'? Also, considering that we still don't have a release until another week, you cannot really say it "sucks". You're trying out the beta version of a software.

      Baloo can be disabled just like everything else.

      Delete
    3. SyamFriday, April 18, 2014 at 8:07:00 AM GMT+5:30

      As explained in Vishesh's blog, the KCM module no longer has an option to disable semantic search :-(
      It can still be disabled if you add your home directory to the list of excluded folders.
      Ref: http://vhanda.in/blog/2014/04/desktop-search-configuration/

      I don't think the situation is optimal and in line with KDE's general philosophy of allowing the user to tweak everything while providing sane defaults.

      Delete
  2. VictorSaturday, March 22, 2014 at 11:22:00 AM GMT+5:30

    Siego -> Seigo.

    On the subject. I hope at least baloo will be possible to uninstall. As for now it doesn't even have a setting to turn it off.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. SyamMonday, March 24, 2014 at 6:57:00 AM GMT+5:30

      Thanks. It's corrected now.

      No setting to turn it off? Huh? That is indeed disastrous. The only good thing about nepomuk-kde/strigi was that one could turn it off.

      Delete
    2. SyamFriday, April 18, 2014 at 8:07:00 AM GMT+5:30

      It seems that if you add your home directory to the list of excluded folders, baloo will be disabled.

      Delete
  3. nomasteryodaSaturday, April 19, 2014 at 5:58:00 AM GMT+5:30

    Did not work for me... I disabled my home directory and it still churned away...even after a reboot. So, I just moved all the binaries in the /usr/bin/ for baloo to a dummy folder. I DO NOT WANT THAT on my system and yes those were yelling all caps for a reason.... If you are not a guru user, then maybe baloo is for you. But for the sake of all hard drives, battery life, etc... make an option to completely disable it. Or I suppose we can all go back to using Gnome...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. nomasteryodaSaturday, April 19, 2014 at 6:05:00 AM GMT+5:30

      and the akonadi_file_indexer ... and possibly all the other akonadi_binaries... Hmmm, gnome is looking pretty good about now.

      Delete
    2. SyamSaturday, April 19, 2014 at 7:37:00 AM GMT+5:30

      Hmm.. Which distro do you use? Do they have a separete package for Baloo/kde-semantic-search that can be uninstalled?

      Delete
    3. nomasteryodaSaturday, April 19, 2014 at 8:56:00 AM GMT+5:30

      Arch ...
      when attempting removal of baloo, this is the result:

      error: failed to prepare transaction (could not satisfy dependencies)
      :: baloo-widgets: requires baloo
      :: kactivities: requires baloo
      :: kdegraphics-gwenview: requires baloo
      :: kdepim-libkdepim: requires baloo

      and going further to issue the "pacman -Rsc baloo" which cascades down all dependencies, we get this result: http://pastebin.com/RvuKgYzp

      So the root of the matter is that KDE depends on baloo now it seems.

      My renaming the files has worked for now, but it should be corrected Time to switch to Gentoo or recompile KDE without the baloo. It really does suck down far too many resources on a system.

      Delete
    4. nomasteryodaSaturday, April 19, 2014 at 9:08:00 AM GMT+5:30

      Posted blurb / rant on Arch forum... we'll see what comes of it.

      Delete
  4. Mike SharkeyMonday, December 8, 2014 at 7:51:00 AM GMT+5:30

    Frankly, I don't really give a rat's behind what these "tools" do, as far as I'm concerned they are useless bloatware. I just wish the distros would stop installing them by default. I've been driving *nix systems for 35 years, and never once have I had a need or a desire for such a thing, and don't, quite frankly see one. Fine, if people want to punish themselves with this rubish, then then can feel free to install the package, but please let's don't punish people up front!...sheesh!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Qt - Enabling qDebug messages and Qt Creator

-
I have been struggling for the past two hours to get qDebug() messages from my Qt 5 application to show up on the 'Application output' pane in Qt Creator IDE on Linux. Finally I found a solution, thanks to a user on Qt IRC channel. To enable log messages in Qt, do the following: Edit ~/.config/QtProject/qtlogging.ini and make sure it has: [Rules] *.debug=true qt.*.debug=false With this, I was getting the messages when I run the application from a terminal. But Qt Creator was not showing the qDebug() messages. To have the messages displayed in Qt Creator, do the following: Qt creator > Tools > Options > Kits, select your kit, find Environment, click change and add: QT_ASSUME_STDERR_HAS_CONSOLE=1 This fixed the problem for me. I thought I should document the full process here as Google wasn't getting me good leads. My environment: Fedora 29 Linux x86-64 Qt 5.11.3 Qt Creator v4.7.2 References: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=12272
Read more

പേര്

-
Image
ഒരു പേരിലെന്തിരിക്കുന്നു എന്ന് പലരും ചോദിക്കറുണ്ടല്ലോ.. പക്ഷേ ചില കുട്ടികളുടെ പേരുകള്‍ കേട്ടാല്‍ ഇത്രയും വേണമായിരുന്നോ എന്ന് തോന്നിപ്പോകും. ഈയടുത്ത് ഒരാള്‍ 'മൃത്യു' എന്ന് പേരുള്ള ഒരു കുട്ടിയെ പരിചയപ്പെട്ടു എന്ന് പറഞ്ഞുകേട്ടു. ഏതാണ്ട് ഒരു കൊല്ലം മുമ്പ് ഞാനും ഭാര്യയും ഞങ്ങള്‍ക്ക് ജനിക്കാനിരിക്കുന്ന കുഞ്ഞിന്റെ പേര് തപ്പിനടക്കുകയായിരുന്നു. സ്കാനിങ്ങ് ചെയ്തപ്പോഴൊന്നും കുട്ടി ആണാണോ പെണ്ണാണോ എന്നൊന്നും ഞങ്ങള്‍ അന്വേഷിച്ചില്ല. പക്ഷേ യാതൊരു അടിസ്ഥാനവുമില്ലാത്ത ഏതോ തോന്നല്‍ കാരണം കുട്ടി പെണ്ണ് തന്നെ എന്ന് ഞങ്ങള്‍ ഉറപ്പിച്ചു. എന്റെ പേരന്വേഷണത്തിലുള്ള ചൂടില്ലായ്മയെ പഴിച്ച് പ്രിയതമ കൊണ്ടുപിടിച്ച അന്വേഷണം തുടങ്ങി. അദ്ദേഹത്തിന് ഒരുപാട് നിബന്ധനകള്‍ ഉണ്ടായിരുന്നു. ആരും കേട്ടിട്ടുള്ള പേരായിരിക്കരുത്, S, U, Vമുതലായ അക്ഷരമാലയില്‍ അവസാനത്തില്‍ വരുന്ന അക്ഷരങ്ങളില്‍ തുടങ്ങരുത് മുതലായ കഠിനമായ നിബന്ധനകള്‍. അങ്ങനെ ഇടയ്ക്കിടയ്ക്ക് ഇദ്ദേഹം ഓരോ പേരുകള്‍ കണ്ടുപിടിച്ച് കൊണ്ടുവരും. ഒട്ടുമിക്ക പേരുകളും ഞാന്‍ വീറ്റോ ചെയ്തുകളയും. ഇത് വായിക്കുമ്പോള്‍ നിങ്ങള്‍ക്ക് ഒരു പക്ഷേ ഞാന്‍ ചെയ്തത് ശരിയായില്ല എന്ന്
Read more

ബിഗ് റേഡിയോ ഇതിഹാസം

-
ഇന്ന് തിരുവനന്തപുരത്ത് 92.7 ബിഗ് എഫ്എം റേഡിയോ പരിപാടിയില്‍ കേട്ടത്..  പരിപാടി: " സ്വീറ്റ് ആന്‍സി " അവതരിപ്പിക്കുന്ന റിക്വസ്റ്റ് രാഗ, യെസ് ഓര്‍ നോ ഗെയിം ... സ്വീആ: ഹലോ, ആരാ വിളിക്കുന്നത്?  റസാക്ക് സ്വീആ: റസാക്ക് അല്ലേ.. "റസാക്കിന്റെ ഇതിഹാസം" വായിച്ചിട്ടുണ്ടോ? റസാക്ക്: ഇല്ല സ്വീആ: എന്താ റസാക്കേ, സ്വന്തം പേരില്‍ ഒരു പുസ്തകമൊക്കെ ഉള്ളപ്പോള്‍ അത് വായിക്കണ്ടേ? റസാക്ക്: ങേ? ... സ്വീആ: അപ്പോള്‍ റസാക്കിനും റസാക്കിന്റെ ഇതിഹാസം ഇഷ്ടപ്പെടുന്ന വായനക്കാര്‍ക്കും വേണ്ടി ഈ പാട്ട് ഡെഡിക്കേറ്റ് ചെയ്യുന്നു... ...  വാല്‍:  മഹാനായ എഴുത്തുകാരന്‍ പിണറായി വിജയന്‍ എഴുതിയ "റസാക്കിന്റെ ഇതിഹാസം" എന്നോ മറ്റോ പറയാതിരുന്നത് തന്നെ ഭാഗ്യം ...  ചോദ്യം: 'ചങ്ങമ്പുഴ' എന്ന കവിത എഴുതിയത് ആരാണ്? ഉത്തരം: അങ്ങനെയൊരു കവിതയുണ്ടെങ്കില്‍ അതെഴുതിയത് രമണനായിരിക്കും! (കടപ്പാട്: കണ്ട് മറന്ന ഒരു പഴയ മലയാളം സിനിമ)
Read more